Product Testing - Trim: Adams, Optimum, Collinite, BlackWow

Leadfootluke

New member
I bought a new [to me] car about 2 months ago. I drive 400 miles a week in Michigan, so the weather is almost always changing. I figured it would be a good opportunity to test some products. I started a wax test on my truck earlier this year, and before getting follow up pictures/video, I sold my truck :doh: I promise I will try to follow through :biggrin1:



I started by washing/stripping the car. The mirror housings were taped down the middle and the product was applied to each side. The strip in the middle is bare plastic, which will allow for a base for comparison.



The first two products used were Opti-Bond [left, inside] and Adam's Super VRT [right, outside]

IMG_6721.jpg




Opti-bond [on the left]: Opti-bond, is very easy to apply and is quite thick. I have applied it to tires, trim, and other plastics with no problems. I have gotten great durability when applied to tires, especially 1:1 mixed with water as it gets great coverage coming out of a spray bottle. I applied it to the mirror housing, and came back a while later to remove any excess residue. The look was very similar to the Adam's SVRT

IMG_6726.jpg




Adam's SVRT [on the right]: The Super VRT, is the waterproof version of their VRT. It smells good [like black magic tire gel], and is very thick. It actually spreads very thin, which I enjoyed because it's incredibly overpriced compared to other dressings. It gives a darkened look [like most dressings], but makes the mirror housings look "dressed" versus naturally dark.

IMG_6727.jpg




On the passenger side of the vehicle, I used what I would consider to be, longer lasting options. The products used were Collinite 845 [left, outside] and BlackWow [right, inside].

IMG_6733.jpg




Collinite 845 [on the left]: 845, on the left, has been my go-to protection on this type of plastic. It was the type of plastic that I had on my truck, and I had several months of durability out of it. It does not look as shiny as most dressings, but darkens the plastic so it looks new. In order to avoid white spots, I use the Wipe on Wipe off approach that Accumulator talks about so much. And after following his direction, I have found this to be a great protectant on various types of trim. You need very little product to get the desired look.

IMG_6731.jpg




Black Wow [on the right]: I have barely used any of my BW, since I got it. I have used it more for restorative purposes versus a dressing. I figured I could get a good idea of it's actual durability with this type of test. I used a foam applicator and very little product. This product is comparable to the Adam's SVRT in how it makes the plastic dark and shiny.

IMG_6732.jpg




Here are a few misc pictures of the mirror housings

IMG_6735.jpg




IMG_6736.jpg




IMG_6738.jpg




This is my almost 3 week update as today was a good day to present recent findings. In the past 3 weeks it was anywhere from 30 degrees to 80 degrees. It rained 5-7 of the days, and I park outside at work for 10 hours a day [6 of which are in the sun]. My car is garaged and gets washed on average twice a week. I have put about 1,300 miles on my car in the last 3 weeks, and here are the results.



The Opti-bond is essentially dead. It is still on the plastic, as the characteristics of it's side are different than the middle, which was not protected/dressed at all. The Adam's SVRT is still beading fairly well, but the looks have diminished. It is no where near as dark as it first was. Neither product have kept the dark finish they started with.

IMG_7035.jpg




IMG_7037.jpg




The 845 and BlackWow look fantastic. The noticeable change is that the BlackWow is not as shiny as it first began, but it is still dark and beads water very well. The 845 is still dark and beads water on this textured plastic like it does on does on paint.

IMG_7039.jpg




IMG_7043.jpg




845

IMG_7040.jpg




Black wow beading

IMG_7041.jpg




Because this is my personal car and I like to dress/protect/test on it, I am in no need of a permanent solution. I am also a huge fan of Meguiar's Hyperdressing, although I figured that my highly diluted solution I use would not be worth testing just yet. Maybe next time I can test those. I will update this thread in a week or two, or when one of the dressings dies off.
 
Nice comparison! I am very interested in how 845 performs long-term. I use either Original Armor All or Poorboy's Trim Restorer...both have good looks but neither last very long. Plus, it always nice to have a versatile product.
 
I honestly had no idea you could use 845 on plastic trim.



And all this time I've been doing my best to keep it away from texture plastic figuring it would stain....
 
dschribs said:
I honestly had no idea you could use 845 on plastic trim.



And all this time I've been doing my best to keep it away from texture plastic figuring it would stain....



Accumulator mentions it often, so I figured I'd try it. Works like a charm on my Mazda!
 
My Wife's '08 CRV is covered in black plastic. 845 on everything and it looks great. An Accumulator tips. KAIO works nice as well.
 
Very useful test! Thank you.



TBH from the 'dry' pics I cannot differentiate a lot, but I am sure that up close differences are much more discernible.



Could I nominate CG new look trim gel and 303 AP as the next 'contenters' on the right (as we look from the front) mirror?
 
Ch96067 said:
Very useful test! Thank you.



TBH from the 'dry' pics I cannot differentiate a lot, but I am sure that up close differences are much more discernible.



Could I nominate CG new look trim gel and 303 AP as the next 'contenters' on the right (as we look from the front) mirror?



I do have 303AP that I could test, I completely forgot about that, but I don't have any CG products. I almost got their Extreme VRT to pit against the Adam's SVRT. If the OB is dead in the next few days I could add 303AP to the mix.
 
How about a nomination for UTTG+? I was waiting for my next big order from AG to get some due to several reviews on its great durability. I've had a hard time with dressings/LSPs on the plastic portion of the bumper covers on my '07 MDX with regards to either streaking or durability (mostly streaking, it is quite a bit of real estate to get a perfectly thin layer on, not to mention the fact that all of the water flows down the vehicle onto the bumper covers).
 
303 would probably wear/wash away like AA does. I've been impressed with PERL's performance in recent testing. I've had it on my window cowl for about three weeks, still a rich look.
 
dschribs said:
I honestly had no idea you could use 845 on plastic trim.



And all this time I've been doing my best to keep it away from texture plastic figuring it would stain....



x2



I would have NEVER thought to use 845 on trim.
 
Thanks for the review. It is not often you see a comparion of Adam's VRT against anything.
 
Bunky said:
Thanks for the review. It is not often you see a comparion of Adam's VRT against anything.



;)



Al, you had good success with the Poor Boys product, correct? I remember you tested a few trim products on your Dakota.
 
I did a side by side with PB's and Black Wow. I thought they were very close with the edge to PB's having the better look but I do believe various trim products work better on some plastics than others.
 
Here is the 1 month update. In the last week, since my last update, I have driven 700 miles with it only raining once.



The Collinite 845 is still going as strong as it did on day 1. It beads well and cleans off very easily.

IMG_7379.jpg




You can still see the tape line between the 845 and the Black Wow

IMG_7383.jpg




When the trim was sprayed down, you can better see the difference in the two protectants.

IMG_7389.jpg




This is the drivers side with the Adam's SVRT on the outside and Opti-Bond on the inside. Neither are visible when the trim is dry.

IMG_7385.jpg




When wet, you can see how each react to water differently, and how there is still a little bit of product left on both sides.

IMG_7396.jpg




The Opti-Bond side looks like water is sheeting off, whereas the Adam's side looks like a dying form of protection.

IMG_7397.jpg




When *lightly* misted, the Adam's SVRT beads fairly well.

IMG_7399.jpg




I recently applied Collinite 845 to the trim on the sides of the roof to show how well it works.

IMG_7426-1.jpg


IMG_7425.jpg


IMG_7423.jpg




After 1 month, I would conclude that the Optimum Opti-Bond did the worse. The trim was visibly dressed through 2 weeks, but before 3 weeks it was almost dead. The Adam's Super VRT looked great the first day, but after 3 weeks, it also looked almost dead. In this most recent test, it was evident something was left behind after it appeared dead, but as a "dressing" it is dead. The Black Wow is still doing its job, and water beads off of it, but it looks spottier than a dressing should. I suppose 2,000 miles of bugs, rain, and other elements may have taken its toll too. The 845 still looks awesome. I can't imagine not using it on this type of trim, unless you want a different look. However, in my opinion, it looks awesome. It's dark, semi glossy, and is super slick. All washed have been done with Optimum Car Wash, with OID as the drying aid/QD.
 
Back
Top