Medium or Mild Detailing Clay

SpoiledMan- Heh heh, I really do need to type up my clay vs. LSP test huh?



To repeat, I spot clay with Sonus green (used others before that) at *every* wash. The often-clayed areas need their LSP redone before the rest of the car, but it's not like five/six/eight gentle clayings make it necessary unless I get aggressive about the claying.



Using the Sonus green, and plenty of Glyde lube, it's pretty easy to glide (sorry about the pun :o ) the clay across the surface of the LSP...it just shears off stuff that's stuck to the surface of the LSP. Yeah, it does take a gentle touch (basically no pressure at all) and not everybody's gonna do it right, but I'm utterly confident that *you* can do this. And yeah, if that stuff has penetrated the LSP to a significant extent then it's a totally different situation and you'll need to rewax by the time you finish the claying.



I bet I sound like I'm all ranting about this topic, but when you consider that I've done the spot-claying innumerable times (however many washes I've done in ~17 years) this is something I'm confident about. I've clayed through LSPs and I've *not* clayed through 'em, and it's pretty easy to tell the difference.



Wonder if the way I'm always working on *my own* vehicles makes a big difference...if I were doing somebody else's car I'd probably have to clay so aggressively that I'd need to rewax :think: The last time I clayed somebody else's car I wasn't very gentle about it ;)



BTW, I really do sympathize with you people working on (let alone the people living with) that stupid-soft BMW paint. That's a good term for it, I'd sell the vehicle, regardless of loss, over [nonsense] like that. The ss lacquer on the Jag is pretty soft (especially the satin-black window frames) but clays (even ones more aggressive than the Sonus green) don't mar it and I'd be bummed if they did.



IIRC that's the same paint that you've marred by all sorts of contact right? Including the sort of contact that would never penetrate the LSP under normal circumstances. Getting back to the clay thing, think of how you can (presumably, I'm sure not talking from experience here...) wax the soft paint and then mar it with a towel or something similar; it's still waxed though, right? I dunno whether it presses the wax down into the paint, or cuts through the wax in some places but not in others...[heck] I don't know *what* happens in those cases, but I bet you'd say "well, I marred it again, but it's still waxed". Same idea with the Sonus green clay.
 
SpoiledMan said:
Don't get excited.;) This was some of that stupid soft BMW paint.

Yeah, well, with the way my luck has been recently I am afraid to even look at my paint. Yesterday I needed to wipe off comment bird left me what it thinks of my detailing "skills". Didn't have any of my "regular" MFs nearby but I had some Meguiar's. So I looked at them and thought "Well, they are not exactly softest possible thing in the world, but this should do if I just very gently swipe with no pressure, right?". Wrong. It laughed in my face as it left swirls.



Plus you know me, I am easily excitable. :bounce



SpoiledMan said:
What would make the clay selective?

Whether it likes you or not? With my ugly face it will not work, not even if I say "pretty please with cherry on the top".
 
Accumulator said:
SpoiledMan-

IIRC that's the same paint that you've marred by all sorts of contact right? Including the sort of contact that would never penetrate the LSP under normal circumstances. Getting back to the clay thing, think of how you can (presumably, I'm sure not talking from experience here...) wax the soft paint and then mar it with a towel or something similar; it's still waxed though, right? I dunno whether it presses the wax down into the paint, or cuts through the wax in some places but not in others...[heck] I don't know *what* happens in those cases, but I bet you'd say "well, I marred it again, but it's still waxed". Same idea with the Sonus green clay.



Yes, same paint. You almost can't look at it. The marring that is left behind from claying happens with out without LSP and must be polished away in both cases. To my way of thinking the LSP is removed where there is marring.
 
bert31 said:
Noob here.



I have just recently been reading autopia and wanted to purchase some clay. My car is a 2000 Mitsubishi Eclipse that has never been clayed. Because the car is almost 8 years old (manufactured in 1999) and has never been clayed, do I need to go more aggressive than mild clay and use medium clay at the risk of micro marring the surface? Or should a pass or two with mild clay be fine?



Back to what really matters here. ;) If it's 8 years old and never been clayed it's going to need polishing anyway. It won't matter what clay you use. Get one of the paint cleaning sponges and save your arms. You can use car wash solution as your lube.
 
SpoiledMan said:
Back to what really matters here. ;) If it's 8 years old and never been clayed it's going to need polishing anyway. It won't matter what clay you use. Get one of the paint cleaning sponges and save your arms. You can use car wash solution as your lube.



A paint cleaning sponge is effective for polishing also? What about a foam applicator? If so, this newb learns something new each time he logs on.



Any brands of sponges or applicators you recommend?
 
Does anyone have a medium abrasive clay they recommend? I believe Sonus has discontinued it Grey Block Clay. When reading the reviews, davidb stated that Magic Clay Blue was a mild clay not a medium clay. Any medium clays you guys and gals would recommend?
 
I bet different people define "mild/fine" and "medium" clays in very different ways ;)



IMO a good "medium detailing clay" would be something that won't mar unless you use it incorrectly. Something like ClayMagic blue or Griot's/Mother's. "Fine" or mild would be reserved for such gentle claying that the LSP remains basically undisturbed.
 
Accumulator said:
I bet different people define "mild/fine" and "medium" clays in very different ways ;)



IMO a good "medium detailing clay" would be something that won't mar unless you use it incorrectly. Something like ClayMagic blue or Griot's/Mother's. "Fine" or mild would be reserved for such gentle claying that the LSP remains basically undisturbed.



So for a car like mine that is almost 8 years old and has never been clayed, Clay Magic Blue or Griot's/Mother's "Fine" or mild would have a hard time removing 8 years worth of built up contamination?
 
Denzil said:
Stick with a mild clay if you have no intentions of polishing it afterwards. Keep in mind that some mild clays can/will induce micromarring. Good luck.

Would the Meguiars clay kit fall into this category? I don't recally every seeing any marring after using it, but I'd like to get the opinon of it from the pros.
 
bert31 said:
So for a car like mine that is almost 8 years old and has never been clayed, Clay Magic Blue or Griot's/Mother's "Fine" or mild would have a hard time removing 8 years worth of built up contamination?





No way! Blue Clay Magic will remove just about any clayable contamination. The only time I've had a need to step up to Red Clay Magic (heavy) is for "faster" removal, not "more" removal. But, after doing so, it requires a fair amount of correction via a rotary.



On a side note, I've done 100's of new car(zero miles) preps and have exclusively used Blue CM and have never run into one case where buffing was needed as a result of the clay marring the finish. This same clay was also used on high mileage vehicles with heavy paint overspray and/or fallout from nearby industrial factories.
 
David Fermani said:
No way! Blue Clay Magic will remove just about any clayable contamination. The only time I've had a need to step up to Red Clay Magic (heavy) is for "faster" removal, not "more" removal. But, after doing so, it requires a fair amount of correction via a rotary.



On a side note, I've done 100's of new car(zero miles) preps and have exclusively used Blue CM and have never run into one case where buffing was needed as a result of the clay marring the finish. This same clay was also used on high mileage vehicles with heavy paint overspray and/or fallout from nearby industrial factories.



Thanks DF, I will try to pick some up this weekend.
 
bert31 said:
So for a car like mine that is almost 8 years old and has never been clayed, Clay Magic Blue or Griot's/Mother's "Fine" or mild would have a hard time removing 8 years worth of built up contamination?



Sorry, I must not've been as clear as I coulda/woulda/shoulda...as David Fermani said the regular blue ClayMagic should work fine. Even the Griot's/Mother's would probably be OK.
 
RedlineIRL said:
Would the Meguiars clay kit fall into this category? I don't recally every seeing any marring after using it, but I'd like to get the opinon of it from the pros.



While I haven't used the Meguiar's clay kit extensively (I tried it on a friend's car), I haven't seen any noticeable marring from it.
 
Been looking at that Ultima Elastrofoam dealie? Have not heard much on it on these last 3 pages at all---is it not that great?
 
Back
Top