Shurhold DA Polisher Review

You need to tell us what you are interested in and what you want it to do. Also budget helps greatly. DO you need 4 doors trunk or hatchback, fuel economy or gas guzzler, is insurance an issue.



I think you get my drift there are many factors that need to be considered. Try Edmonds.com for some helpful advice too. Also there is a thread here about buying websites that can be helpful as well.
 
<blockquote class='ipsBlockquote' >

<em class='bbc'>Originally posted by Guess My Name [/i]
<strong class='bbc'> Try Edmonds.com for some helpful advice too. [/b]</blockquote>Excellent advice Guess, but it's Edmunds.com. Sorry dude! :(
 
<blockquote class='ipsBlockquote' >

<em class='bbc'>Originally posted by Guess My Name [/i]
<strong class='bbc'>Whooooops I tries really hard not to typo. [/b]</blockquote>Ha!! And you make fun of Floni... ;) Just kiddin' Guess!
 
I got a chance to play with our newest addition to the machine polisher line up- The Shurhold Dual Action Polisher. I love polishers to the extent of any man roaming this Earth, in fact my dream job would likely consist of making polishers for a living, so this is always fun for me.

The Shurhold Dual Action Polisher delivers, period, and is quite an impressive machine that will find a home and a happy user because it has some unique features not seen on other polishers. You may not be as familiar with the name Shurhold as you are with Blackfire, but that is because this companies roots are in the boating and yachting industry. Because of the nautical intention of this machine it is outfitted with a HUGE 20 foot power cord with a ground-fault circuit interrupter, or GFCI. This is idea for those of us who like to DA damp sand with our electric polisher, as well as ideal for those who work in wet conditions or on a boat.

Opening up the box, I was impressed to find everything I could want (minus multiple backing plate sizes) in a polisher, from extra brushes to multiple handle styles, as well as an attractive carrying case.
shur1.jpg

Included with the polisher
-Shurhold Dual Action Polisher
-5 inch flexible backing plate
-Bail handle and mounting bolts
-Side ?stick? handle
-Allen wrench
-Thin backing plate wrench
-Tote bag with side pockets
-Additional brushes
-Owner?s Manual

The machine itself is small, weighting only 4.8 pounds. Compared to other DA polishers it certainty feels smaller and easier to control. Like most of newer Dual Action Polisher the Shurhold features a 5/16th inch stroke, and accepts most standard backing plates (as well as the excellent 5 inch plate that is included).
shur1andhalf.jpg


The speed dial on Shurhold Dual Action Polisher is located under the power cord an controls a 500 Watt motor, which seems to be plenty for serious correction work.
shur2.jpg

Speed 1: 2500 OPM
Speed 2: 3200 OPM
Speed 3: 3900 OPM
Speed 4: 4600 OPM
Speed 5: 5500 OPM
Speed 6: 6500 OPM

The power switch is located on the right or starboard side. Because I polish with my left hand over the head of the machine, I sometimes found it a little difficult to find the switch. The switch slides forward, turning the machine on, and bringing the OPMs up to the speed set on the dial. If you press the switch forward a little further it will lock into place. Push it forward again to release.
shur3.jpg


The Shurhold polisher comes with enough accessories to let you find what works best for you.
shur4.jpg


shur5.jpg


The power cord, which features a very generous 20 foot length also has a circuit interrupter , which adds an additional level of safety when working in conditions where water could be present. (Use common sense!)
shur6.jpg


Finally the Shurhold Dual Action Polisher comes complete with a carrying case with dual side pockets which do a great job of holding the machine and it?s accessories.
shur7.jpg


shur8.jpg


So how does it perform?

This thing generates some seriously quick pad rotation which and seems almost impervious to bog, particular when used with 5.5 inch pads. It seems to have a lot of power on the top end. The noise levels are not the lowest, nor the highest of the popular DA?s, but in the middle. Vibration is very well controlled an a non-issue if you are used to DA polishing.

In terms of paint correction, all of the modern machines are extremely competitive and versatile, so it will always come down to personal preference. The Shurhold is a slightly different take, and one that I prefer.

shur9.jpg

 
From Properboatcare

Electrical Specs
Rated Voltage: 120V AC
Frequency: 60Hz
Rated Current: 4.2 Amp
Rated Power: 500 Watt

Mechanical Specs
Variable Speed: 2,500-6,500 OPM
Backing Plate: 125 - 150mm ( 5" - 6" )
Pad size: 140 -150mm (5.5" - 6")
Net Weight: 2.2kgs (4.8Lbs)
Power Cord: 20feet w/ GFCI

Speed Chart
6-Speed Orbits Per Minute (OPM) Settings: Recommended speeds are as follows:
1 : 2500 OPM Waxing & Buffing
2 : 3200 OPM Waxing & Buffing
3 : 3900 OPM Polishing & Cleaning
4 : 4600 OPM Polishing & Cleaning
5 : 5500 OPM Removing paint defects and Swirls
6 : 6500 OPM Removing paint defects and Swirls


SH-3100 Price: $149.99
Special: $139.99
 
Leadfootluke said:
From Properboatcare

Electrical Specs
Rated Voltage: 120V AC
Frequency: 60Hz
Rated Current: 4.2 Amp
Rated Power: 500 Watt

Mechanical Specs
Variable Speed: 2,500-6,500 OPM
Backing Plate: 125 - 150mm ( 5" - 6" )
Pad size: 140 -150mm (5.5" - 6")
Net Weight: 2.2kgs (4.8Lbs)
Power Cord: 20feet w/ GFCI

Speed Chart
6-Speed Orbits Per Minute (OPM) Settings: Recommended speeds are as follows:
1 : 2500 OPM Waxing & Buffing
2 : 3200 OPM Waxing & Buffing
3 : 3900 OPM Polishing & Cleaning
4 : 4600 OPM Polishing & Cleaning
5 : 5500 OPM Removing paint defects and Swirls
6 : 6500 OPM Removing paint defects and Swirls


SH-3100 Price: $149.99
Special: $139.99
Click to expand...

Thanks, anything on waranty?
 
Thanks for the review ... it seems to me that this the same as a Griots DA but with a less powerful motor and a different cord configuration.
 
The best boat detailer out here, a personal friend of mine, had one of these given to him for evaluation and since its a little toy PC compared to the heavy duty rotaries he needs and kills with regularity to detail gelcoat, he gave it to me to try out for a few weeks.

Its smaller, pretty noisy, doesnt have a more positive rotation like the Meguiars G110V2, and the on/off switch is in an akward place for a right handed buffer like me.

Personally based on my needs and usage of it, I place it on line with the P/CableXP, and based on me being able to kill the rotation very easily, not as good with that aspect as the Meguiars G110V2..

Again, its all in what you personally want to do with it, and how you use it; my boat detailer expert says it will never be able to cut it in a gelcoat/rotary world, but perhaps it would be good for something inside the boat that required light buffing.

Me, I dont care for it... :)

Dan F
 
Stokdgs said:
The best boat detailer out here, a personal friend of mine, had one of these given to him for evaluation and since its a little toy PC compared to the heavy duty rotaries he needs and kills with regularity to detail gelcoat, he gave it to me to try out for a few weeks.

Its smaller, pretty noisy, doesnt have a more positive rotation like the Meguiars G110V2, and the on/off switch is in an akward place for a right handed buffer like me.

Personally based on my needs and usage of it, I place it on line with the P/CableXP, and based on me being able to kill the rotation very easily, not as good with that aspect as the Meguiars G110V2..

Again, its all in what you personally want to do with it, and how you use it; my boat detailer expert says it will never be able to cut it in a gelcoat/rotary world, but perhaps it would be good for something inside the boat that required light buffing.

Me, I dont care for it... :)

Dan F
Click to expand...

Dan,

I could have written this same response 2 months ago. I was not a fan of the DA. However, after reading rave reviews for almost 2 years I broke down to find out firsthand what all the fuss was about :-t

After recieving mine I started to expierement with all kinda different ways you can use this machine. I have used heavy cut polish w/light cut pads and light cut polish w/heavy cut pads (and everything inbetween) polish using heavy pressure on fast speeds to light pressure on low speeds (and everything inbetween) I must say, I am thoroughly impressed at how my machine is preforming :-B

I have also found that I can achieve in most cases a 90% correction using a 1 step process and have a car LSP ready in 1 hour. Therefor I'm not only saving myself time, but am able to save my clients dinero :money:

As for you freind, yes I can see why he insist on using a Ratary. Nothing cuts dried out chalky white gelcoat better then wool and rocks-n-bottle. But IMO there is no better machine to have for both novice and profesional then a DA :2 cents:

I must go now. I beleive I smell my cinnamon rolls burning. Can't have none of that Da Rules!


bmw5541 said:
I agree with gdal. It looks just like the Griots polisher. A longer cord though.
Click to expand...

My GG has a 25' cord :wizard:
 
Stokdgs said:
The best boat detailer out here, a personal friend of mine, had one of these given to him for evaluation and since its a little toy PC compared to the heavy duty rotaries he needs and kills with regularity to detail gelcoat, he gave it to me to try out for a few weeks.
Click to expand...

I'm not sure I would say it's alittle toy compared to a rotary, but I accept the fact that a lot of guys who are very good with rotaries never took the same time to learn how to use a Dual-Action, so of course they get better results with the machines they know how to use.

A know people who rock on a DA and I know people who rock on a rotary, and it has been my experience that on in a few cases have the skills translated across the board.

Its smaller, pretty noisy, doesnt have a more positive rotation like the Meguiars G110V2, and the on/off switch is in an akward place for a right handed buffer like me.
Click to expand...

The Shurhold, in comparision to my two G110V2's achieves a much faster pad rotation.

Personally based on my needs and usage of it, I place it on line with the P/CableXP, and based on me being able to kill the rotation very easily, not as good with that aspect as the Meguiars G110V2..
Click to expand...

I wonder if I have got two bad V2's or you have a bad Shurhold, because my experience, as well as other's I have spoken with has been reversed.

Again, its all in what you personally want to do with it, and how you use it; my boat detailer expert says it will never be able to cut it in a gelcoat/rotary world, but perhaps it would be good for something inside the boat that required light buffing.
Click to expand...

I think if we are dealing with chalked out gel-coat then it will require professional restoration (high speed with a lot of abrasive material), but for a lot of people who invest the time in learning to DA polish to the highest level, they will find that this machine provides more then enough power to handle most polishing situations.
 
Shoot, am I the ONLY one around here that still uses Rotaries ? :)
Sure seems like it, you think ?

Will there ever be a day when Todd and I actually agree on something? :)

Maybe its time I take a leave of absence or something...

bibi


Dan F
 
Stokdgs said:
Shoot, am I the ONLY one around here that still uses Rotaries ? :)
Sure seems like it, you think ?

Will there ever be a day when Todd and I actually agree on something? :)

Maybe its time I take a leave of absence or something...

bibi


Dan F
Click to expand...

I still use a Ratary from time to time. Dana still uses one all the time. No need to exit out Dan :chillpill: something else to keep in mind is that Todd spent a considerable amount of time testing this piece, then spent even more time doing a write-up on his findings. Then you come along saying the machine is p.o.s. You gotta expect there will be some disagreement on that. PAC is not a non-profit organization :-B

Hope you stick around Dan, I always find your post very refreshing. I really hate it when every response is the same. Makes me fill like I'm communicating with robots :doh:
 
Stokdgs said:
Shoot, am I the ONLY one around here that still uses Rotaries ? :)
Sure seems like it, you think ?

Will there ever be a day when Todd and I actually agree on something? :)

Maybe its time I take a leave of absence or something...

bibi


Dan F
Click to expand...

Dan,

It's okay to have different opinions on the merrits of a DA vs. a rotary. That is why we have this forum.

Don't leave us here at TID. Your posts are always interesting and informative.

Keep on posting my friend!!!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top