It is definitely true that threatening someone physically over their opinions is way over the line. However I think maybe you miss the point of why WE are HERE... Maybe I should focus even more to MY reasons for being here and I think it can be inferred that at least some of the others here will agree.
I am here to learn about detailing. What works well, what doesn't. How different products are used best and for what application. What products and techniques yeild the best result and what may lead to disaster. Whats new and hot. I enjoy reading and posting and, I think, that at this point I might actually have some things to contribute. I have done much testing on my own with different products and sharing my results with others may make it easier for someone else looking for similar results. Opinions are just that... We all have them and we all know that they can differ. I also think that many of us here are "obsessed", OCD, buffing bonkers, or just plain addicted to tinkering with detailing and car stuff. I have seen some heated discussions over different products, but rarely have I seen those discussions turn ugly. Often I think they are funny. If what I saw was boring or distasteful I moved on to other posts. These passionate discussions will sometimes occur. So what... It usually just makes me want to go out and test for myself. Some of the results are almost indistiguishable to me, whereas they are like night and day with others. Last I looked, this is what America is all about. The freedom to agree or disagree with one another. There may even be some people here that may have some financial interests in pushing certain products. So what, the discussions root out the good and the bad.
I looked at the waxtest site and thought that it was interesting that their results could be so different from the results that our members seemed to be getting. I also felt that perhaps their "scientific method" was somewhat lacking. It would have been better for me if their testing methods and observation methods were truly scientific. I don't even know if that is possible. I found some of their "comments" to be weird and I don't think that durability was included as an "issue". Their site became the butt of some sarcastic posts here. I don't think these innocuous posts even came close to crossing any lines. If there were some individuals who complained anonymously via email, so what. The specific threats that are mentioned however were totally unwarranted and definitely crosses the line! I sincerely hope that they don't back down from their duty to report this to the proper authorities and I hope that it doesn't discourage them from going forward with their experimentation on the web site. Maybe they will get it right eventually and it will be a benefit to everyone...
H (Damn, now I have to go wet sand the cars to work off some of this anxiety!) :bounce