PLEASE help choosing LCD TV!

Spilchy

Spilchy

New member
Hey guys, I need your help. After a zillion years with my Amex card, I have built up enough membership rewards points for a lot of merchandise. I have decided I want a new television.



I have no clue about selecting LCD televisions. I am confused about what I am reading and don't know which one to select.



My TV would only be used for watching TV shows and movies and NO games, video editing, etc... Just basic TV use.



Here is my selection below. Anyone who knows LCD's, please make me a recommendation! I have listed them by size and manufacturer.



Thanks for all of your help! :)



Sony® M-Series LCD HDTV 32� Model KDL32M4000



Samsung 32" HD LCD TV with Integrated ATSC Tuner and 8000:1 Contrast Ratio Model LN32A450



Samsung 37" HD 720p LCD Television Model LN37A450



Toshiba 37" Regza® LCD TV 720p Model 37CV510U



Toshiba REGZA® 37 in HD 1080p LCD Television with 15,000:1 Contrast Ratio (No Model number listed)



Toshiba 42" HD 720p LCD Television Model 42AV500U
 
Hey Seth!



You state just basic TV use but does this include plans to view HD signals with your new TV?



I would suggest that you personally view each of your choices since "look" varies by person.



For example my LCD TV produces some fairly bad ghosting or pixelation patterns during fast movement. This drives me nuts but my fiancée doesn't notice it. From what I've read "Response Time" is what causes this. Here is some information about that:

LCD TV Response Time, Why it's Important



Watch some of the signals when you are looking at the TV's. Slow moving pans and near still shots are used often and they do look great. BUT watch it when they show something that is relatively fast paced like a snow skier coming down a mountain. If you notice any of the ghosting I'm referring to it will eventually drive you crazy too. :)



Good luck man. :xyxthumbs
 
themightytimmah said:
I'm *very* partial to Samsung, but your best bet is really to see each in person. If I had to bet offhand, I'd take the 720p Samsung.
Click to expand...

+1.



I have the model year before the current 32" Sammy (3253) and it is excellent.
 
I would look for a lcd that has a 120hz refresh rate,1080i.I think most lcd's have 2 hdmi inputs.I just got a sony xbr5 52" a few weeks ago,120hz refresh rate makes most dvds HD like & Blu Ray looks awesome.
 
hands down the new samsung 650 series lcd. just bought a 52 in. last week, incredible! it has 120Hz automotion which pretty much negates motion blur and has 50,000:1 contrast ratio the best on any brand so far. 1080p, the works you name it's got it. also imo 1080p or go home thats gonna take awhile to be outdated but will be the broadcast norm soon enough. you wouldn't put nu-finish on a benz don't treat your eyes to anything less than the best.
 
reaper34 said:
1080p or go home thats gonna take awhile to be outdated but will be the broadcast norm soon enough. you wouldn't put nu-finish on a benz don't treat your eyes to anything less than the best.
Click to expand...

In Seth's case, since everything he is looking at is under 42", 1080p shouldn't be a deciding factor.



Why spend the extra money on a set that runs 1080p when one may not have a signal and/or hardware to broadcast it and won't be able to tell the difference anyway?



Check out this article on CNET for more information:



HDTV resolution explained - HDTV World - CNET.com

"Despite the obvious difference in pixel count, 720p and 1080i both look great. In fact, unless you have a very large television and excellent source material, you'll have a hard time telling the difference between any of the HDTV resolutions."
 
reaper34 said:
also imo 1080p or go home thats gonna take awhile to be outdated but will be the broadcast norm soon enough. you wouldn't put nu-finish on a benz don't treat your eyes to anything less than the best.
Click to expand...



It will not be the broadcast norm for a very long time. They are switching to 1080i or 720p for broadcast. It is just too much bandwidth to switch everything to 1080p.



There is no need for 1080p without a 1080p source(blu ray, ps3, computer, etc)
 
We have that Sony model in our bedroom and think it is great. We looked at all of the diffrent brands. When placed side by side the Sony always looked better than the Samsung. (clearer, better color) We checked at 3 different stores to make sure it wasn't the source material. This is just my opinion. I know plenty of people that think the Samsung looks just as good or better.
 
well I guess I meant the 1080p will be the last to be old technology so you would be ahead of the game. but whatever you do please get something thats running 120Hz you'll thank yourself later.
 
bumoftheday said:
It will not be the broadcast norm for a very long time. They are switching to 1080i or 720p for broadcast. It is just too much bandwidth to switch everything to 1080p.



There is no need for 1080p without a 1080p source(blu ray, ps3, computer, etc)
Click to expand...



Exactly, great advice. 1080p is many many years in the future. We barely have 1080i/720p now a days, and it took them many yearst to get it aboard. If you do get a 1080p which I think you should, only because you are ready to watch (Blu Ray, HD DVD). I like the Hitachi's, Pioneer Elite. Also go big, Good Luck!
 
themightytimmah said:
I'm *very* partial to Samsung, but your best bet is really to see each in person. If I had to bet offhand, I'd take the 720p Samsung.
Click to expand...





Ditto.



Back when I was searching, I remember Samsung consistently being the market leader for LCD and the prices weren't too bad (compared to the alikes of Sony and such).
 
I have always believed in not spending today's dollars on yesterday's technology. Get 1080p/120hz.



I bought a Samsung 46" - 1080p LCD last year and couldn't be happier with it. That is currently in the master bedroom and I have a 1080i Sony 50" plasma in the home theater (5 year old TV!) still going strong. Samsungs have very good brightness and color rendition (as best as you can get with an LCD before looking to plasma for deeper colors).
 
Roishe Cheng said:
I have always believed in not spending today's dollars on yesterday's technology. Get 1080p/120hz.



I bought a Samsung 46" - 1080p LCD last year and couldn't be happier with it. That is currently in the master bedroom and I have a 1080i Sony 50" plasma in the home theater (5 year old TV!) still going strong. Samsungs have very good brightness and color rendition (as best as you can get with an LCD before looking to plasma for deeper colors).
Click to expand...



I would be willing to bet that by the time 1080p takes over, you could've bought a new and better set for less than the premium you paid for your TV over a perfectly good 720p TV.
 
Thanks for your help fellas. I can only choose from the list I posted.



Looks like I will go for the 37" Samsung.



None of them are 1080i and 120hz. They are 760 / 60hz. But I won't be using Blue Ray, games, etc...



Hey, it's for "free" since I am using my points. I'll go look at them first as Best Buy or something.
 
bumoftheday said:
I would be willing to bet that by the time 1080p takes over, you could've bought a new and better set for less than the premium you paid for your TV over a perfectly good 720p TV.
Click to expand...



Takes over?



I feed my computer into the Samsung and display 1900x1200.



My PS3 also displays Bluray in 1080p.



What "taking over" are you waiting for? Broadcast 1080p? Some of us 1080p owners don't only use the sets for broadcast use.



The price of LCD panels are always dropping. I am an early adopter, always have been, yes, us early ones always pay more.
 
I admit I did not read the response but it's TV only...no games, etc, why not consider a plasma ?

Panasonic if they have that in the rewards programs.

Pioneer Kuro is better....and would be my 1st choice, sans membership point or not.....
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top