Eh, this is kinda a jumbled-up mess of a response; I`ve cut/pasted stuff to death, but here goes anyhow..
Accumulator - regarding flat series. If I’m correct, the flat series are for DA machines as they don’t resist unforced spin, seemingly by the extra pad material and therefore more product to soak into it, making it heavier and harder to spin. Do you agree with this? Or is it something I should discover by using?
I gotta admit I`m behind the times when it comes to pads (I basically don`t need to do correction any more and don`t touch my polishers for years on end), so I`m the wrong guy to ask
BUT you`re on the right track as there are flat/curved, thin/thick, etc. varieties of pads and using the right ones will make things go better (and easier). A few sorta-random thoughts follow, maybe something will be helpful:
- DO NOT BELIEVE STUFF WITHOUT A GOOD REASON FOR DOING SO, NO MATTER WHO SAYS IT (me included)
- Be especially leery of "info" from people who have skin in the Sell Stuff Game (no matter who they are)
- Figure out how stuff works so you`re making informed decisions (looks like you`re doing that already

)
OK, those are the generalized biggies IMO

Now, more to the point:
-I do not think it`s a matter of "thick pad full of product = harder to spin = that`s the diff"
-Thinner pads will generally be more aggressive as they don`t "flex" as much in use
-The dimples in some pads will collect cut-off paint and used-up product, neither of which is good, period
-No matter what anybody says, I do not believe you can correct any vehicle with one pad unless you clean it all the time
-Yeah, you can go through a lot of pads and, *depending on the product*, a lot of product too
-Some compounds/polishes work best in small quantities (e.g., HD Cut and Polish) while others work best with a *lot* (e.g., the Kevin Brown Method)
-Hard/soft is difficult to generalize, but there are some rules-of-thumb...what`re we talking about here?
Well, I see that one we`re discussing is...
My wife’s grand Cherokee... it’s an off white with absolutely heinous paint. Little rusty iron spots everywhere.. Blegh.
Get some *GOOD* Inspection Lighting so you can see what`s going on with that light colored paint. Sounds like a prime candidate for a Chemical Decontamination, specifically stuff that`ll remove Ferrous Contamination. Might want to use Clay or a "Clay substitute" too. That [stuff]might clean off a lot easier than you`d expect.
Not sure why CG says [what they do]...
I suspect they want to make their products look more appealing so they can sell more. Heh heh, much as I despise cynicism, you might could use a little dose of it when it comes to what those vendors are sayin`

No, I`m not flaming CG, the only product I`ve tried of theirs was OK.
As for hard vs soft paint.. looks like the short answer is it makes no difference, or at least doesn’t matter. The process is the same regardless, test spot, adjust as necessary starting with least aggressive combo...would it be fair to say the softer the paint, the faster it’s removal?
Right, and learn to err on the side of caution, i.e., "much better" vs. "perfect". And yeah, softer paint cuts off a lot faster/easier along with being trickier to do the Finish Polishing (i.e., eliminating any hazing or "micromarring" caused by the aggressive steps).
Just for clarification, my cotton towel/air gun question was directed specifically at the pads, not the paint. Don’t worry! I promise I won’t take a haggard, abrasive towels to my paint job! Lol.
Heh heh, OK, good

I too like cotton towels for wiping off my pads and using compressed air on `em (but watch where that product dust goes).
Also.. at what point do you look at your pad and say “eh, time to change ‘er up”
Without having the experience of feel yet, what would you recommend, and why? Is it based off dry dusty presence on the pad? Hot to the touch? Or cleaning with say, air or a pad brush while it’s on just doesn’t make a noticeable difference anymore?
IMO you shouldn`t even get close to the point of "dry dusty presence". Or "hot to the touch". Or let it go so long that your cleaning appears ineffective. Heh heh, see...I keep getting back to "just get out another one" every time we discuss this! But I`ll admit I`m kinda fanatical about it and it`s easy for me to spend your money on a lot of pads. The stuff that builds up on pads is, in the general/functional sense...BAD all the way around.
I’ve had my eye on a proper [pad] cleaner. Even just doing the dishes with dawn and a sponge it takes forever to wring it all out so I’m totally on board with that suggestion. I was just more surprised than anything that you could even use dawn in a pinch.
I still just use an All Purpose Cleaner ("APC") or the old Dawn Power Dissolver...but people sure do like the dedicated Pad Cleaners and the one I`ve tried (BlackFire, perhaps?) did indeed work better. Stokdgs loves Snappy Clean and he`s a reliable source of info even though he and I don`t always see eye-to-eye (gee, who does?!?).
You’re right about the CG sales to newbies. All the fancy brands of compounds and polishes out there I find fairly intimidating...
Yeah, confused consumers spend more $ once they get over the analysis-paralysis
The self diminishing properties just made me feel warm and cozy about not excessively working my paint, but now that I think about it.. I can’t imagine the compound magically knowing when to diminish, so I could still over compound before it stops itself. Hmm..
[/QUOTE]
I myself generally prefer NON-diminishing abrasives because they cut the way they cut all the time (generally speaking...) and you don`t have to keep working them until they break down; you can stop any time without it being an issue. But hey, that`s just me and I do use diminishing ones now and then. But yeah...by the time you work a product long enough for it to break down you might be working it too long for the paint`s health.
..If you guys could just let me know if my findings are correct, it would be much appreciated! Currently working at a nuclear power plant ..
Ah, sounds like you`ll grasp how little things can be important, good. And you *do* sound like you`re on the right track and doing well figuring it out. Just beware of claims designed to separate you from your money. Not saying anybody`s *lying* to you, but, well...be skeptical in the scientific sense.
Oh, and BTW...FWIW I don`t like those soft black Finishing Pads. Not even for applying wax. They`re generally too soft and have too-small pores for my taste. The idea behind Finishing Pads is basically just that the pad itself doesn`t have any cut so all the cut comes from the product.
Another BTW/FWIW, I generally try to match my pads/products (aggressive pad + aggressive product/mild pad + mild product), but will sometimes use an aggressive product with a milder pad just to tone it down a bit. I myself don`t like to go the other way and use a mild product with a harsh pad, even though some people do that. Truth is...back in the day there were very few varieties of pads and/but we still did just fine without today`s huge assortment of choices. It`s all about *functional* diffs and personal preferences.