I owned (actually wife’s car) a 2000 Jetta VR6 GLS, which we have since sold after 2 years and 34k miles and purchased the 2000 BMW 328i. Here are my impressions and recommendations from my experiences:
1. I felt the materials used in the interior could not be touched for the price range the dash and door panels felt as good of not better than most cars costing twice as much. The fit and finish was also superior in to any car in the high teens low twenty’s range (new). All the switches, knobs and button had very expensive and positive tactile feels to them. However, I thought the cup holders were a very poor design and seem flimsy that blocked the climate control and radio knobs when utilized. The plastic hinges in the storage compartment also were not durable (broke twice). Carpeting was ok. We never had problems with rattles and buzzing.
2. Very fun to drive for the $$$ money but too softly sprung with too much body roll for my liking. The VR6 offers plenty of power for both off the line starts and for passing at high way speed. Test drove a 1.8T but I felt in the stock form it was lacking in grunt at highway spends. There was no instant acceleration for passing on two lane roads at 60 mph. VR6 did suck the gas (much more than the 2.8 liter inline 6 in the BMW) and ran very rough when cold (but would smooth out after 5 minutes) dealership claimed this was normal for the VR6 (not sure if I believe them). I thought it had a very good sporty ride. It handled very well in snow/ice and rain.
3. Reliability: questionable. We had numerous problems. Automatic transmission was replaced at 15k miles, two front axles were replaced, climate control fan in dash board was replaced, both power mirrors were replaced, numerous micro switches were replaced, had a coolant leak, wheel bearing replaced, and the in dash CD player was replaced. Thankfully all these problems took place in first 24k miles and were fixed under warranty. Drove from 24k-34k with no problems.
4. They depreciate like no tomorrow. There are also many of them in on the used car market (which relates to the high depreciation) because so many were leased. For the size of car they are expensive new but I thought a much more “rich� feeling car than their competitors. I think you can find good deals on them in the used market. I would look into some type of certified pre-owned program for the warranty and or a very good after market warranty.
Over-all it is a great car to drive and in the used market a pretty good value. However, the reliability is a big question for me. From my understanding and talking with the dealership they experienced a lot of problems with the 1999 and 2000 cars. Allegedly the 2001 and newer are much better (know the transmission and axle problems we experienced were quite common and the dealership had technical bulletin about it stating that revisions had been made to the axles and transmissions after a certain build date).