I just moved from CA, but my rates were going up while I was out there. It's just the industry. It sucks right now. Unfortunately, for your age and with a partial accident, 4WD SUV, that isn't too surprising for me. I'm a few years older than you, driving a 97 Accord SE (not the EX engine), clean record and I was paying about a grand a year.
I just shopped around for insurance out here. Check out 21st Century. I just switched to them (less than half price of what they others were doing) and have been happy. They are a good carrier.
I'm going to get GEICO for my Motorcycle out here. They aren't a bad company at all. Not sure if you have any other insurance (homeowners or renters) but if you do, check with them and see if they can give you a discount. Also, check with AAA. That's who I had and although they were going up, they still weren't bad.
Important things to look for are customer service/claims hours and also their AM Best or S&P rating (should be an A- or higher). The only bad thing about GEICO, 21st century, AAA, etc is that you don't have an actual agent. You get whoever answers the phone at the customer service center.
I have a friend in Oceanside that works for Farmers. If you'd like a free quote, email him at
[email protected]. Tell him Scott Hunter recommended him to you. The accident thing might hurt you, but that will be everywhere.
Also, call GEICO and check into revising your policy. If you were licensed at age 16, you know have 9 years of driving experience, which is a rate drop. Also, make sure all your info is correct (annual mileage, garaged, lojack, etc) and look into dropping comprehensive coverage as your vehicle is getting a little older. Also, if you have the money in the bank, look into raising your deductible. Going from $250 to $500 can make a big difference.
Bottom line, I'd at least go to
www.21st.com and check. They've been aggressive trying to get new business and have been kicking out some great rates. Good luck and let me know what you find.