III said:
Good points so far. I was just curious because when people use a rotary or da, these products spin in a circular motion. I was just wondering if people do the same when applying by hand.
THAT is the point I usually make when participating in these "which motion" threads. The machines do NOT go front-back, and they do (at least) as nice a job as anyone working by hand.
Marring is marring, whether circular or straight, whether caused by contamination or by harsh products. It's all just scratches in the paint. The point is to remove marring (by using increasingly fine abrasives, to the point where they don't leave any marring of their own that you can see) and not reintroduce it (by not scratching/swirling the paint by abrading it). The direction is NOT a factor in whether or not the marring occurs. That's a matter of the softness of the paint vs. the hardness of whatever is touching it. The direction DOES NOT MATTER when it comes to whether the marring is there, though it DOES make a little difference in how noticeable it is.
As far as "some products should be used up-down on sides, front-back on horizontal surfaces", etc. I've never heard an objectively convincing argument to support that. It's not like the products dry in some "directional" way, that makes them reflect in one certain direction but not another
I REALLY don't mean to sound like I'm flaming or otherwise :nono
:argue the people who say "front to back", but *IMO* it's just not logically supportable. Sorry that sounds so harsh..

I'm probably coming across as pretty contentious.