One more update:
I sent Autogeek a nice e-mail explaining my situation yesterday. Today I received a call from one of their sales rep telling me it was there fault that I got the wrong formula, and that they we're going to send me a new bottle of the new formula free of charge. He also asked me if I wanted to add anything to it since I already had free shipping, and since I can't find NXT glass cleaner locally anymore I picked that up. Once again I tip my hat, and praise Autogeek for their awesome customer service.
I guess I will try the newer formula come spring.