We, my wife and I have bought several Weathertech mats and floor liners in the past. They were not paper thin, nor did ours scuff up. I am a fairly large,230 pounds and were anything from steel toe boots to my favorite sneakers-Nike.
Now, I recently bought a Ford Taurus, Weathertech didn't have a trunk liner so I took a change at AutoAnything and bought Loyds. They stunk, and were nothing more than cheap plastic that had been cut out of a big sheet of the stuff, no lip around the edge. I called and returned the.
I bought a Husky trunk liner, and gen-u-wine Ford rubber mats . They look pretty good and I got a deal from the dealer.