Get the peanut butter out. Mask off the paint around the trim and use a cheap microfiber towel to rub the PB in, then buff it off with a clean MF. It will work, I've been restoring a '93 Prelude with black interior and the PB has made the center console, dash and other vinly trim look brand new, and the effect will last as it's cleaning it, not just a coverup. As a serious detail junkie, I tried ArmorAll multipurpose cleaner, Zaino plastic cleaner, Zaino glass polish, Zaino leather cleaner, clearcoat rubbing compound, denatured alcohol and Dawn dishwashing liquid. The PD buried them all!