Rotary Advice

jdthompson

New member
I'm in the UK and would like to get a polisher. I'm hoping it will be for occasional use only as, to my mind, once your paint is in good shape you shouldn't need to be getting a polisher out every week?



We don't have as much choice as in the US - we can get Porter Cables but you have to import them and pay duty and get transformers so you end up at around the $250 mark - that's a lot to pay for the amount I'm hoping to need to use it.



This got me looking at rotarys as you can get them quite cheap off eBay (I accept that for week in, week out use it makes sense to go for a known quality make), for example - Rotary seems to have the necessary variable speed control, I'm not paying much attention to the included foam pads but that's about the starting price in the UK for that sort of thing.



It looks very similar to the Vector at Proper Autocare and the Chicago Electric at Harbor Freight (I can't believe you guys can get those things for $25 :))



I've done a bit of reading and on the one hand I see a lot of posts saying avoid rotary's you'll trash your paint unless you train with a Jedi Master for 50 years, but there are also articles such as this About Rotary Polishers that suggest that if you use the right pads and products and keep the speed low you're as safe as you would be with a random orbital.



The car is a 1999 Saab 9-3 convertible in Cosmic Blue Metallic, the paint is in good shape with some light swirling.



I suppose what I want is some advice, if I were in the US I would simply get a P/C but as I said it's not that cheap and simple over here and I'd rather not consider spending that sort of money unless it is totally and utterly the only workable option, but likewise there's no point going for something cheaper if I'm likely to do a ton of damage.



cheers,

Paul
 
I might've already answered this on another thread, sorry to be redundant if that's the case.



Remember that the "article" is really just ad-copy from a business that wants to sell you a rotary ;) No, it's *NOT* as safe as a RO unit. That's what's good about it and what's bad about it.



No way would I have only a rotary especially if I weren't very experienced with it. No, they're not all *that* tricky, but there are times when you need something milder and I do mean *NEED*. Spend the money for a PC (or a euro-voltage Cyclo) and get the rotary later if (big "if") you find you really need it.



And note that even *VERY* experienced rotary users like Mike Phillips at Meguiar's almost always follow up their rotary work with the PC. Get the milder tool first. You don't want to be penny-wise-pound-foolish and, heh heh, consider how much it'd cost if you *did* have an "oops" with the rotary and had to have something repainted.
 
Accumulator said:
Spend the money for a PC (or a euro-voltage Cyclo) and get the rotary later if (big "if") you find you really need it.



good advice. in most cases, you won't need the rotary.
 
Good idea!



Please let us know how it works. Some of us are curious about this adjustable-speed Cyclo knock-off. At least I *think* that's the adjustable one, I can't really decipher the description on that link.
 
Will do.



Now I need to source some pads.



I believe Lake Country is what I want but I need to check if I can source them cheaper from the States than the UK places that do them (shipping will be the decider).



Paul
 
Unless you're dealing with some very soft paint, I'd just go by price. I usually just use the Cyclo brand pads which others find just *too* cheap/etc. and they work fine for me.
 
Yeah the problem is that in the UK generally you just can't get that sort of thing locally, and pretty much all the online stores seem to get their stock from the states.



I'll give you an example, Lake Country 4" pads $9 for 2 from Autogeek, $6 for 2 Cyclo pads from Properautocare.



The only place I've found in the UK that does 4" pads are doing Lake Country for $8 each, so if I can get a few imported myself I think it has to be cheaper assuming I find somewhere that will do regular USPS shipping at cost price.



They call the UK Treasure Island for a reason you know :)



cheers,

Paul
 
Back
Top