I too have non-clear coated polished aluminum wheels. Eagle One mag and aluminum polish is by far the best I've tried. I tried the "Never Dull" and didn't like it too much. The cotton swab-like texture is harder to work with, leaves a black mess on your fingertips and does not leave a spectacular shine. Try the polish with a old microfiber towel. Shines better and much easier to work with. Mothers aluminum polish works pretty good too.:up