Well, I redid my famous propeller test and took some pics. I had slightly different results this time, but the order of magnitude was approximately the same. Since I used up all my sample sizes of KLASSE SG, that product was not involved in the test. Note that in the last test, it mirrored the results that I had with Zaino........
Anyhow the line up was NU FINISH, Pinnacle paint cleansing lotion, Klasse AIO, Mothers cleaner wax, Zaino Z2, and 3M Imperial hand glaze.
Here is a pic of the lineup before the test........
http://albums.photopoint.com/j/View?...nce=0&res=high (sorry guys photopoint ate my before pic!!!)
I was trying to get a feel for the cleaning strength / abrasive nature of these products. I used an old boat propeller that I had recently painted with rust-oleum BLACK spray paint.
I used 100% white cotton applicators that were made from cutting up an old T-shirt. I prepped the propeller with 3M SMR to remove any oxidation or loose paint and then washed it in DAWN dishwashing liquid.
For the test, I applied a few dabs of each product on their respective applicators and rubbed with medium constant pressure in back and forth strokes about 10 times. Here are the results (this pic works):
It is hard to see in the pics (sorry about the quality), but my conclusions are: (in order from mildest to harshest)
1. Zaino Z2 / 3M imperial hand glaze (TIE)
2. Pinnacle paint cleansing lotion
3. Mothers Cleaner Wax / Klasse AIO (TIE)
4. Nu finish
Nu finish was definately the harshest. The black on the applicator was DARK and consistant. KLASSE and Mothers were next in line, with a lighter more greyish appearance. PPCL was next, and seemed to be quite mild. For Zaino and IHG, virtually no black paint was transferred onto the applicator.
I know this is far from a scientific test, but I did have fun doing it on a rainy saturday. Make your own conclusions........
Bookmarks