what`s better for light swirls: megs #9 or ssr1?

[III]

I think both of these products are the same abrasive wise, but would one work better than the other?

[Bill D]

Does it have to be one of those two only? I`d vote for PI III MG, Menzerna FP or 1z MP

[1 Clean WS6]

I think it is six in one basket have dozen in the other with these two products. The SSR1 gets the nod from me only because it is a direct sun safe product.

[JasonD]

My vote would be for 1ZPP or PI III MG



#9 - too many fillers

1ZMP - too mild

FP - too hard to work without a rotary

ssr1 - never worked with



JMHO

[04BlackAV]

I`ve used #9 and recently SSR1.Both are weak when it comes to swirl removal.But as a follow up or a finishing polish I`d have to say SSR1 wins.No oils or fillers and ease of use make it a better product to use.

[III]

Originally posted by Bill D

Does it have to be one of those two only?

Yes.

[Bill D]

I trashed my #9 long ago, I guess get the other one, hopefully less disappointment

[JasonD]

Well, if it absolutely has to be one of those two I say do one door with one and the other door with the other and pick one.

[III]

Originally posted by 04BlackAV

I`ve used #9 and recently SSR1.Both are weak when it comes to swirl removal.

I`m talking minor/very light scratches by the way.

[kartoon]

I haven`t used #9, but found #82 similar to SSR1.

Meguiar`s stuff is easier to get but Poorboy`s smells nicer and produces perhaps just a tad better shine.