Rupes UHS vs. Menzerna 3 in one

[dontlikemyname]

Ok, so I have searched and searched and found a lot of posts of each product. So I am looking for a straight up poll answer. For a vehicle with swirls, possibly a few RIDS, to perform a quicker and somewhat still quality service & shine (of course not car show perfect, as I don`t expect that from an all in one)...

Which do you think is better? Menzerna One Step 3 in one (with a Rupes Polish Pad) or Rupes UHS (with a Rupes UHS Pad)?

Why?

Have you personally used both?

Thanks for the feedback and let the battles begin!

[jrock645]

UHS doesn`t a wax, as the Menzerna product does so this isn`t a great direct comparison. Either way, with RIDS involved, I wouldn`t expect a lot from either one. I`d think either would do well with general swirling, though. Only used UHS once. Nice product, easy to use, though I`m still not a huge fan of the UHS pads- just don`t like how they feel.

[Brewins]

UHS polish is a royal PITA to clean out of pads.

[512detail]

I`d be looking at WG UBER AIO vs the Menzerna 3 in one since they`re both AIO

the UBER is a little further down the cut chart than most AIO but not sure how it compares to the Menz, never used either but just can`t bring myself to pay for any more polishes or I`d have the UBER AIO

my goto AIO is PWC reg or blue with a Urofiber pad on speed 4 or 4.5
stupid easy/ user friendly on all aspects from applying to working to removing and cleaning pads

but I`d very much like to try the WG Uber aio - don`t really hear much about it

[512detail]

I just realized I didn`t address the UHS which I have (the pads too) and I like the cut but the pads take some getting used to
never recall much issue cleaning them, however, but I had some bouts with sling which led me to using different pads (I found I liked squeezing the UHS pads a little bit to soften them up before I applied a few drops of UHS liquid which seemed to ease my sling issues which were all user induced im sure)

UHS would most likely cut much more than the Menz 3 n 1 but as already stated it does not leave any protection so you`re not really comparing the same type product so it I`d say your choice between the two would involve $ to buy in if you don`t have either or the UHS pads vs necessity of a UHS setup that can cut really good but you`re gonna have to top OR a three in one, which I don`t know about you but in the history of truly applying an AIO and done I`ve only done it once...I just can`t stop myself from topping things.

[rlmccarty2000]

I would use UHS then top it with something. Of course a test spot with both will get you the truest answer.