DG 105 vs. Collinite 845/476S

[mikebai1990]

Alright, perhaps this is very bad question, considering there are many variables (type of car, type of paint), but have any of you guys tried both Collinite`s carnauba waxes and Duragloss`s sealants? I have some Collinite, but I`m looking to see whether the 105 sealants can provide a better shine. I`m looking first for durability, and second shine.



To make it clearer, let`s make it DG601+DG105 vs. Collinite 845. All with proper prep (full polishing, claying) to make slim the variables down a bit. I`m curious about durability comparisons as well as "looks" comparisons.



I previously had shied away from using the DG system because it seems annoying having to layer with a 24 hour cure time. However, the more praise I read and the comments I see, the more I want to try it out. Also, I`ve had some issues having the Collinite last the 4-5 months that others have managed. Since I`m somewhat close (well, not really) to finishing my tub of Collinite 476S, I figured it might be time for a change. The prices are about the same, so the money won`t be too much of a concern.



Thanks :)

[Brian_Brice]

i would suggest doing a side by side comparison and whichever one you like better remove the opposite. and take pics and show us. :)

[imported_grease]

I`ve used both alot. 105x2 + 476s is my winter combo. I`ve used both separately as well, and on a dark blue metallic, I much prefer the 105. Much more shine, great metallic pop. Honestly I found the durability about the same (1 layer vs 1 layer). But since you want 1 or the other, Id suggest the 105, if only to try something new.

[violentveedub]

Hopefully I`ll be able to comment on this soon as I have some 105 coming in and I`ve used 845 in the past.



I really like 845 but I`m looking for something that sheds dirt better in winter and is more durable than FMJ in the summer. It seems like 105 is my year round solution...

[mikebai1990]

VaSuperShine, I kinda doubt that the pictures will really make for an accurate comparison. But maybe I`ll do half DG105 and half Collinite and compare at the very least, durability, if not looks.



grease, I didn`t know that you could put Collinite on top of DG 105. Are there any bonding issues between the carnauba and the sealant?



I figured that the 105 might provide a better shine compared to the Collinite. I`ll probably see for myself soon! I`m getting an order ready from AG. ONR+DG105+DG601 :)

[imported_grease]

grease, I didn`t know that you could put Collinite on top of DG 105. Are there any bonding issues between the carnauba and the sealant?

I never had any problems with bonding. I found the 476s applied as easy on 105 as it does on naked paint. The only problem I had was getting the wax outta such a small diameter opening. :)

Im a big fan of both products.

[phamkl]

How well does 476S shed dirt?

[TigerMike]

I have used 105 ever since it was introduced and have also used Collinite 476S a while back. IMO, DG is FAR easier, actually seems to last longer, gives a much better shine, and seems more resistant to water and grime. I applied 476 once as a comparison to 105 and have not used 476 since...

[mikebai1990]

Very well! I guess I`ll be ordering the 601+105 and trying it out!

[TigerMike]

I have actually been testing 105 with Zaino CS and am very impressed with the result. It`s like a super-durability and shine combo. The CS on top of 105 locks in the shine and the durability/protection never seems to falter. I think it`s probably the most durable combo I`ve ever used, which is saying a lot!

[mikebai1990]

By how long do would you say does the 601 extend the protection offered by the 105? The website says double, but I don`t think that`s really possible :) About 6 months?



Also, in terms of versatility, can 105 be applied to vinyl/rubber trim like AW? Any staining?

[TigerMike]

No, it won`t be double for sure. 601 will probably add a month or two, max, but it also depends on your conditions. My car is outside 24 x 7 and 105 holds up wonderfully. Yeah, probably 6 months give or take...



I do not apply 105 to rubber/vinyl and I don`t think it is meant to be...AW is more versatile in that regard. The thicker 105 formula just doesn`t lend to that type of application. I haven`t noticed 105 has ever stained anything...

[imported_grease]

^^^ Ive used 105 on a variety of surfaces and its also landed on other surfaces and I havent had any staining with it either.



105/476s has been a potent winter combo for me.

[Brian_Brice]

mike,



i meant for your own benefit not for pictures sake. if you like the look/feel of one side better in person go with that combo/single app.

[mikebai1990]

Mmhm, I know what you mean. I have my dad`s friend`s car to work on in the course of the next week, and I`ll be doing just DG on it. However, on our own cars, when I get the chance, I`ll probably do a comparison with 476S/DG105 left half/right half.