Jester7677- *MAN* that large point size makes your post easy to read
I have the exact same pitting on my M3 sedan. Two areas have it and it seems to come from two causes (the two areas are very similarly pitted but there are some subtle differences):
1) The repainted hood didn't display this at all until I go somewhat agressive with the rotary and then it had it *everywhere*. It appears to be from a crappy repaint job, and the term "solvent pop" comes to mind. My painter agrees that this could be it...it's sorta like tiny bubbles in the clear that become exposed as you remove the very top-most layer (of clear). The pits are quite uniform and look like "exposed bubbles" when examined under magnification. My hood is utterly *awful* looking, far worse than what's in your pics.
2) The front area of the roof *did* display this a little before some *very* aggressive rotary work, and now it's worse. This seems to be from road debris impact and the rotarying made it more obvious. Think of how a window looks when shot with a BB-gun: small entrance hole, conical wound channel, large exit hole; I suspect the same sort of thing can happen with stuff hits clearcoat at a high velocity as it looks *exactly* like that under magnification.
In both cases, the only solution is a repaint.
Oh, and our Audi A8 has some *nasty* water etching and our Denali XL has pitting from similar environmental [stuff]. The etching is completely different and the pitting is *also* different from what your pics show. Those don't get *worse* with rotary work, but they don't get much (if any) better either. They might benefit from wetsanding, but I'd rather not take off that much clear. These don't really *require* a repaint the way the similar-to-yours pitting on the M3 does.
Gee...sorry this was all so downbeat
