Lcd Vs. Plasma

stiffdogg06 · 10-23-07, 10:14

I plan on getting a new tv. And I was what everyone has or been looking to get.

Advantages/disadvantages of each would be nice. I want something 40" probably. What size do you guys recommend? What contrast ratio do you guys like?

It would be wall mounted no matter what if that matters.

Cooter · 10-23-07, 10:22

I have a 37in Toshiba Regaza lcd in my bedroom. Its been great so far. Its 720p. But all in all i'm really happy with it.

WilliamHBonney · 10-24-07, 04:03

Lets talk later today. Shoot me an AIM I used to sell these part time seasonal and know quite a bit.

Grimm · 10-24-07, 05:08

I'll be interested in seeing the replies as well. We're looking to buy a TV soon, something between a 37" and 42". I'm leaning towards LCD because of the burn in issue, but I don't think it will really be an issue and plasmas seem to be cheaper most of the time. It will be interesting to see what prices look like for the holidays.

TigerMike · 10-24-07, 05:09

Plasma is on the way out, IMO. And, I wouldn't necessarily use contrast ratios to compare LCDs...manufacturers can determine contrast ratios differently (no standard), and therefore the numbers may not be at all comparable. The best determination is use your eyes in the stores along with the contrast ratios and see if you can actually notice a difference between TVs with different ratios. Some you can definitely tell, others it's pretty hard....

There are pretty good 37" and 40-42" deals out there, or you can go all the way to the high end and pay over $2K. Frankly, spending more than 2 grand for a "better" TV is not a wise decision IMO, considering the obsolescence and new technology introductions coming along. That $2K TV will be replaced with a better, probably cheaper TV, with better technology in a year, so I'm all for buying a good value right now. Have a look at the Toshiba REGZAs (they have 37 and IIRC a 42" that are a great value), also look at the Samsungs, and Sony's....IMO, those are the brands that I've noticed have PQ above the rest for the price. The Toshibas are probably the cheapest, followed by Samsung, and then Sony (always count on Sony to hold the high price ribbon).

jsatek · 10-24-07, 05:13

I think the plasma picture is better than an LCD picture. I personally have 2 plasma and 2 LCD in my home. The new LED LCD's look interesting, too new to tell though.

A 40" TV is for a pretty small room, good rule of thumb is multiply the TV size x2 and that is the recommended seating location. 2 X 40" - 80" (6'-6")

ZaneO · 10-24-07, 06:05

Plasma looks fantastic when it has the right source (high-def, DVD, etc.). For day-in and day-out TV watching on an average video source (cable), *I* really prefer DLP (specifically Samsung).

I will say that there are many different factors that could affect this decision.

Setec Astronomy · 10-24-07, 06:17

Quote:

Originally Posted by jsatek

A 40" TV is for a pretty small room, good rule of thumb is multiply the TV size x2 and that is the recommended seating location. 2 X 40" - 80" (6'-6")

Wow, that's my problem! I just measured and I sit 10.5' (126") from my 32" TV, so my TV is half the size it should be! Seriously, that sounds like a formula from someone who wants to sell big TV's...

SamIam · 10-24-07, 06:44

I don't think its too far off. I have a 65" DLP which I love, and I sit about 9.5 or 10 Feet away.

Grimm · 10-24-07, 07:10

FYI, according to CNET's site, for a 42" TV, the viewing distance is 5.3 to 10.5 feet.

I still can't quite get over the thought of spending so much money on a TV. That's why it's so hard for me to decide. I want to make sure I spend it wisely. All I can say is it better last at least 15 years.

jshillin · 10-24-07, 08:10

I think Plasma's have a better picture, especially through HD. I have and LCD and a Plasma and the 42" Plasma seems to have a much better picture.

BlueZero · 10-24-07, 08:43

Quote:

Originally Posted by Grimm

I still can't quite get over the thought of spending so much money on a TV.

I'm with you. I have a 27" tube TV now and would like something bigger. The other thing I don't like is that all the TV shows aren't wide screen so that sucks on a wide screen TV. Just think of all the detailing products you could buy with that much money.

I have two already picked out if I ever decided to get one... lol