Goodyear TripleTreads or Michelin Hydroedge

gofastman · 08-27-09, 09:08

Need some new tires for a car im giving to my sister who is a new driver, wet traction and emergency maneuverability are a big priority. I have a set of dedicated snow tires, so winter traction isn't that big of a deal.
I have driven a car with the Goodyears and they seem great. Has anyone used both of these tires that can offer a direct comparison?

Greg Nichols · 08-27-09, 09:49

I have tripletreads on a honda oddy and LOVE them in the snow, had the Hydro in snow.....accident waiting to happen.

Cheers,
GREG

08StangGT · 08-28-09, 11:18

check tirerack.com. There are numerous reviews for about every tire made. LOL

gofastman · 08-28-09, 11:28

Quote:

Originally Posted by 08StangGT

check tirerack.com. There are numerous reviews for about every tire made. LOL

most of the reviews are misleading though, who is gonna spend $500 on something and tell you it sucks? not to many people.
case in point, BFG Traction T/A's:
good reviews, but these are some of the worst tires on the market!

f150smith · 08-28-09, 03:24

I put a set of the Hydroedge on my wife's Cadillac a few years ago and love them. The handling and traction are exceptional. Not long after I got them we had to drive to NJ and 90% of that drive was during a tropical system rain. There seemed to be no lose of traction even at 65 to 75 mph on the interstate with water everywhere. THe only 2 drawbacks, IMO, are that they are uni directioanl and can only be switched front to back on the same side. The other thing I noticed after they had about 25,000 or 30.000 miles on them is that the road noise from them seems to increase with wear. The noise is more noticable on concrete freeways than it is on asphalt and with the car shut up and the stereo going it's not that bad, but it is there. They currently have about 45,000 on them but still drive and handle well.

Hope this helps

jfelbab · 08-28-09, 06:05

Quote:

Originally Posted by carn00bie

most of the reviews are misleading though, who is gonna spend $500 on something and tell you it sucks? not to many people.
case in point, BFG Traction T/A's:
good reviews, but these are some of the worst tires on the market!

Another opinion, FWIW.

The BFG Traction T/AT was rated based on 5,630,872 driver miles. It got a respectable rating, 5th within it's class. Here is how it stacked up to other tires in it's class: Consumer Survey Results By Category

Bear in mind that the Standard Touring (ST) class is not what one would call a great performance tire.

If you compare some of the lowest rated tires on this list you will find that they are higher priced than the BFGs so wouldn't you expect their owners to rate them high based on your assumption that the ratings reflect the price users paid?

In my experience, the TireRack ratings are pretty good. It's not like you are only getting one persons opinion there.

Again, this is only an ST class of tire and not a thoroughbred by any measure.

buzzb · 08-28-09, 06:50

I've owned both sets of tires. Goodyear TripleTread on the wife's Honda Accord and Michelin HydroEdge on my Infiniti G35. Both are good tires, handle great in the rain, but the biggest difference was how they wear. The Michelin's seem as good today (after 35k miles on them) as the day I bought them. Both of them are a bit noisy on a concrete highway (not asphalt- they were both fine) but the Goodyear's wear much faster in my experience. Which means they get noisy sooner, lose some of the traction sooner, and have to be replaced sooner. I got tired of replacing super sporty low profile tires every 25-30k miles and went with the Michelin's for my car. I am completely happy with that decision and my wallet is much happier too. Hope that helps.

gofastman · 11-04-09, 06:52

I just found the Goodyear Eagle GT's, they look very promising and they're only $60 a pop for my size!

DFWSRT8 · 11-07-09, 10:17

Look into Vredestein ultrac sessanta's

they're what im currently running and the performance of them, compared to michelins, BFG's, nittos, and ESPECIALLY goodyears, is second to none!
Hydroplaning=nonexistent.
wet and dry traction is great, and they are SCARY quiet. =]

DFWSRT8 · 11-07-09, 10:21

and if anyone is interested in them, let me know...i can get them at an awesome price!

Since you have a setup for the winter, these tires are wonderful for all other conditions.
Im running them in 275/40/20 fronts and 315/35/20 rears on my Jeep SRT, and coming off of OEM goodyears on it...ill never go back. plus you cant beat the look of em!