I am of the old school mentality that squeaky clean is best, and Mcguires does the job well. I am not looking for smell (not that smell is not important) rather I am looking for a product that does the job, and allows me a few extra things like
SG,
AIO, a few micro fiber towels, and some
Pinnacle if the budget allows.
So the choice is yours, but if you check out a lot of the posts, you will find that Mcguires Gold Class is a pretty popular wash, and has a pretty good track record. Just read some of the past posts, and make your own conclusions.
For the record Detailking, ShowroomLincoln, Brad B., and others take detailing a bit more seriously than non-professionals like myself, so realize that they do have a bit more experience behind their comments.