Good to hear your great results with the bissell. What Bissell cleaner was it? The portable hand held ones, or the bigger ones with rotating scrubber brushes?
Well for that one make up spot, try a spot remover made for cloth. Click on the banner on the top right of the site. It should go to Classic Motoring Accessories (CMA) Then click on interiors. There should be a few cleaners on that page. Eimann Fabrik Spot Remover, Stoner Xenit, and Eagle One Zap to name a few.
Happy detailing

Jason