Dammit, I want the truth!

flyfishindawg · 01-19-09, 06:50

OK, here's the deal. Once and for all, please, please, someone give me a definitive answer on the following:

I have read on more than one forum that buying expensive leather treatment products is a grand waste of cash for most leathers except for very high end cars. Is this, or is this not a true statement?

I only want answers from experts so that I can put this out of my mind once and for all.

I apologize for my tone but it seems like this topic just goes on and on and on with no clear answer.

bufferbarry · 01-19-09, 06:55

you'll get a lot of answers on this but if it means anything i have used a lot of them and to be honest i have found you get what you pay for!

Setec Astronomy · 01-19-09, 06:56

I think the definitive answer is that there is no one "truth" for every car, every user, every situation.

Slickery · 01-19-09, 07:08

You treat the coating on "most" modern leathers. These coatings need to number one be cleaned and number two have a product that will guard against drying and UV. I personally like a two step, but there are one steps that are pretty good. I don't know if you need an "expensive" product, but it is a good idea to keep your leather clean and protected. For what it's worth I use the Zaino twins, mainly cause I like the non oily protection and the smell, but there are good otc products too. Mothers reflections and believe it or not turtle wax is a good local product too.

XRL · 01-19-09, 07:10

Quote:

Originally Posted by Setec Astronomy

I think the definitive answer is that there is no one "truth" for every car, every user, every situation.

So then there is no truth, as a truth should be universal.

I think it all depends on what you're going for in your results. Some people are satisfied with different levels. For many years I thought that just a normal wash and wax and wipedown with some armorall wipes was good. But now I've realized that it is not nearly good enough.

It also all depends on what you consider to be expensive. As with everything, the law of diminishing returns says that at some point you will get less benefit from every dollar you spend. So it might cost you an extra $50 for an extra 5% gain, as opposed to the lower levels where you can get a 2000% gain for $10.

Holden_C04 · 01-19-09, 07:22

Why would the leather in very high end cars require different treatment from the leather in more modest vehicles?

longdx · 01-19-09, 07:33

Quote:

Originally Posted by Holden_C04

Why would the leather in very high end cars require different treatment from the leather in more modest vehicles?

There are two distinct leather processes that are used on vehicles. The less expensive method is that the color is applied like a coating to the leather on the seats. You will usually find this on less expensive applications.

The more expensive process is a true vat process where the leather is submerged in whatever color. The color is absorbed into the leather ( as comparing to having a color basically sprayed on)making it a much more durable process than the one above.

The problem with the first process is that the coloring can be scrubbed off over years of use and temperature changes can dry out the coating/color. True leather (either application) needs to be treated periodically to maintain its looks and durability. The cleaning steps needs to be modified with the less expensive process as cleaning can actually take up the coloring.

mblgjr · 01-19-09, 07:46

This won't help much...but...

I've used Leatherique on BOTH coated leathers; "pleathers"; and nicer high-end leathers. IT WORKS ON ALL OF THEM!

I've tried Zaino; PB LeatherStuff; Eagle Ottowa; Meguiar's; Lexol and Opt. Protectant Plus/Leather formulas.

As far as making the leather surfaces soft, supple, and clean...the Leatherique wins.

I didn't think it could be "that great" and was VERY skeptical for a long time. However, for the money I spent on all the other stuff and was dissatisfied with; I should have just bought the Leatherique to begin with.

Just my opinion...

RDAutosport · 01-19-09, 07:53

Quote:

Originally Posted by mblgjr

Just my opinion...

It is my opinion too, I recommend Leatherique and I have tried many other products and none of them compared IMO.

Regards,

Rich

Holden_C04 · 01-19-09, 07:54

Quote:

Originally Posted by longdx

There are two distinct leather processes that are used on vehicles. The less expensive method is that the color is applied like a coating to the leather on the seats. You will usually find this on less expensive applications.

The more expensive process is a true vat process where the leather is submerged in whatever color. The color is absorbed into the leather ( as comparing to having a color basically sprayed on)making it a much more durable process than the one above.

The problem with the first process is that the coloring can be scrubbed off over years of use and temperature changes can dry out the coating/color. True leather (either application) needs to be treated periodically to maintain its looks and durability. The cleaning steps needs to be modified with the less expensive process as cleaning can actually take up the coloring.

From your description, the two processes are almost identical in terms of the end result and, ignoring cost barriers, would require the exact same treatment (as I understand it based on your description).

longdx · 01-19-09, 10:03

@Holden C04:

The answer is yes and no. Yes, because both need to be treated to maintain leather's pliability: essentially protecting the end product in drying out and cracking.

No, in that the cheaper process will have diminished durability. If the leather "coating" for lack of better words is compromised than one has to be careful in the cleaning stage.

OTC all in one products are usually a better bet for the cheaper processes. Leatherette seems to be highly regarded.

XRL · 01-19-09, 10:25

Does this apply to only natural leather or to the pleather/leatherette/vinyl "leather" found in your average car as well?