Redcar guy does a comparison a few posts down, but to tell you the truth I don't think his picture shows the truth. The black magic is extremely shiny and DOES fling/sling(whatever you want to say) off. I really really like the turtle wax finish 2001 tire gel in the flourescent green bottle. I am sure DK can attest to that . It leaves a moderately shiny look and dries completely and lasts at least a week.