[sevenrd]

Thanks for all of the replies!

In the past, I've lived with a cushy Acura RL and a bone-jarring MX-5 with an aftermarket suspension. There are things I liked and disliked about both. As far as the different dynamics of the G and the S2000, I'm sure I could live with either car. I realize I'd sacrifice some comfort choosing the S.

What it may come down to is reliability, and it's difficult to get a concise handle on this, as researching both cars brings up some issues that some owners have had. On the G forums there are quite a few oil consumption issues I've read about. On the S forums there are some differential issues some members have had. That said, no matter what car is researched, I realize some people are always going to have one with mechanical issues, some will not.